I read this interesting article in the New York Times from the May 8,2008 edition, called Biodegradable Home Product Lines, Ready to Rot.
Here's a new one....
Would you believe some furniture companies are claiming that their furniture will biodegrade. Scientists and other experts disagree.....in a closed landfill little if anything biodegrades.
“'I see a new generation of marketers who are looking at biodegradability as a panacea to solid waste,” said Steve Mojo, executive director of the Biodegradable Products Institute (bpiworld.org), remembering the “biodegradable” diapers and trash bags of decades past. Mr. Mojo continued, 'There is no data that I’ve seen to support manufacturers’ claims that any plastics will completely biodegrade under landfill conditions. Tightly packed, covered and relatively dry, landfills are not exactly designed for biodegradation,' he said.
To some industry observers, like Joel Makower, executive editor of GreenBiz.com, which covers the “greening” of mainstream businesses, “biodegradability seems like a noble attribute but an irrelevant concept. You also have to ask, Is it reasonable to assume that a product will go into a system that will allow it to degrade? Is there a snowball’s chance it would be put on a compost pile?'”
According to the article, "Mr. Makower described a notorious experiment called the Garbage Project, wherein researchers from the University of Tucson excavated the contents of landfills and discovered layers of mummified natural objects.
'Hardly anything had broken down,” he said. “Carrots had been mummified for 50 years, and you could tell for how long because of the headlines on the newspapers, also intact, found alongside them.'”
An interesting article and food for thought.
My advice, as always for green home furnishings: Beware about claims about green furnishings. Do your homework and do not listen to sales pitches unless the information is backed up by another reputalbe source.
But the best quality furniture you can afford so that it doesn't end up in a landfill. Save unil you can afford good quality. But in general, buy products you don't have to throw out.
Recent Comments